During the various engagements and reviews, it is clearly established that urban developments are likely driven by more unorthodox aggregates, which usually run unexamined.
For example; Governance is typically effected by structure of governing bodies, their effectiveness & empowerments, along with defining the professional skills & eligibilities to practice, ending up with the skills that are critical not as tools, but as visionary & outside the limited and traditional boxes.
Also, enforcing M&E methodology and techniques will enable proper and comprehensive quality control on performance & OKRs rather the usual quantitative techniques.
This would logically explain the success gaps among nations, cities and communities, despite the governmental executive & legislative support and facilitation: it is - with no offence; a soft skills gaps.
The following article shades many unspoken lights on the challenges that urban development would encounter.
Cairo Metropolis - Expense and Distress
Metropolitan capitals and megacities epitomise urban development, offering immense potential for economic growth, cultural exchange, and technological advancement. These urban areas, home to millions, drive national and global economies through concentrated resources, talent, and infrastructure, fostering innovation and diverse cultural activities. However, rapid development also presents challenges like overpopulation, inadequate infrastructure, environmental degradation, and social inequality. Robust and sustainable planning is essential for housing, transportation, and public services. Addressing environmental and social issues is crucial for ensuring these cities' sustainability and fostering inclusive growth.
The development of metropolitan capitals worldwide presents a mix of successful and unsuccessful stories, each offering valuable lessons in urban planning, policy-making, and governance. For instance, Tokyo's success can be attributed to its advanced infrastructure, strategic urban planning, efficient public transport, and sustainable development practices. On the other hand, cities like Lagos, Jakarta, and Dhaka struggle with challenges such as overpopulation, inadequate infrastructure, environmental degradation, and poor disaster preparedness, highlighting the need for more effective urban planning strategies.
I oversaw the development of the Greater Cairo Region Strategic Development Vision (GCR-DV) as part of the UN Strategic Development Program's Projects. The goal was to create innovative policies and inclusive governance to take advantage of urbanisation while minimising its negative effects. Now, I'm part of a team working to evaluate the GCR-DV framework after a decade. We're developing a comprehensive evaluation framework that combines quantitative analysis with qualitative examinations to provide a balanced and thorough assessment of the GCR-DV and the city's transformation.
The preliminary main questions that need to be addressed to support the appraisal framework are: What were the original objectives and targets of the GCR-DV plan, and how do they compare with the current outcomes? Which areas have seen the most significant deviations from the original plan, and why? How have the development projects affected historical cultural heritage and local communities, particularly slums and less affluent areas? What measures were taken to involve community members in the planning and implementation processes, and were they sufficient? What are the main factors contributing to the displacement of residents, and how can these be mitigated in ongoing projects? How effective have investments in infrastructure, healthcare, and education been in addressing the needs of underserved populations? What environmental impacts have been observed due to the urban development, and what steps are being taken to address them?; How are current policies ensuring equitable access to resources and opportunities for all residents?; What best practices from other metropolitan capitals can be adapted to improve Cairo's urban development strategies?..etc.
In summary, the Quantitative Metrics include urban growth and infrastructure, economic progress, social changes, environmental impact, etc. In contrast, qualitative analysis includes public opinion and satisfaction, expert analyses and academic studies, media reports and case studies, etc. Via comprehensive data collection, balanced perspective, and stakeholder involvement, it is understood that the actual city's transformation has seen significant achievements but faces notable challenges. Preliminary findings reflect that the establishment of the New Administrative Capital, the Cairo Metro and Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) expansion, and the mega upgrading projects like the development of the Maspero Triangle reflect positive developments in GCR infrastructure and urban planning are ambitious projects address critical issues such as traffic congestion and overcrowding and signify a commitment to revitalise historic urban spaces that contribute to Egypt's vision for a more developed and prosperous future, fostering economic growth and improving the overall well-being of its people. Nevertheless, significant discrepancies have resulted in a noticeable imbalance and displacement within the city's slums and urban areas.
Additionally, sustained investment in healthcare, education, and public services, particularly in underserved areas, was essential and a priority to bridge infrastructure gaps and promote fair and balanced development. Efforts to enhance public participation in planning processes remain necessary to ensure all voices are heard and considered. Implementing policies prioritising affordable housing and equitable access to resources can help mitigate social inequality and foster a sense of community. Furthermore, addressing environmental concerns, such as improving waste management systems, reducing air and water pollution, and increasing green spaces, will enhance the overall quality of life for Cairo's residents. Integrating smart city technologies can improve efficiency in resource management and urban services, leading to a more sustainable and livable city.
A more inclusive and transparent approach is imperative to address the needs and concerns of all community members. Emphasising inclusive development is crucial to minimise displacement, support affected communities, and ensure that investments in sustainable infrastructure contribute to long-term resilience. Ultimately, the success of the GCR-DV plan depends on a holistic approach that combines economic growth with social equity and environmental sustainability. By learning from international best practices and tailoring solutions to local contexts, Cairo can transform into a more inclusive, resilient, and thriving metropolitan capital.
For more information
No comments:
Post a Comment